Photo of author

How Much Does Plato’s Closet Pay for Jordan Shoes?

Are you a sneakerhead looking to sell your beloved pair of Jordan shoes? If so, you might be wondering how much Plato’s Closet, a popular thrift store chain, is willing to pay for them. Plato’s Closet is known for buying and selling trendy, gently used clothing and accessories, and Jordan shoes are definitely on their radar. In this comprehensive guide, we will delve into the topic of how much Plato’s Closet pays for Jordan shoes, providing you with all the information you need to make an informed decision.

Understanding Plato’s Closet’s Buying Process

When you bring your Jordan shoes to Plato’s Closet, their buying process begins with an assessment of the condition, brand, style, and market demand for the specific pair you have. The condition of your Jordan shoes plays a significant role in determining their value. Plato’s Closet looks for shoes that are in good condition, with minimal signs of wear and tear. While some scuffs and creases may be acceptable, extensive damage or noticeable flaws can significantly decrease the amount Plato’s Closet is willing to pay.

The brand and style of your Jordan shoes also contribute to their value. Certain Jordan models and collaborations are more sought after by collectors and enthusiasts, which can drive up the price Plato’s Closet is willing to offer. Additionally, market demand plays a role in determining the price. If there is high demand for a particular Jordan shoe at the time of evaluation, Plato’s Closet may be willing to pay more for it.

Factors Affecting the Price of Jordan Shoes at Plato’s Closet

When it comes to assessing the value of your Jordan shoes, Plato’s Closet takes several factors into consideration. One crucial factor is the overall popularity and desirability of the Jordan brand. Jordan shoes have a dedicated following, and certain models, such as the Air Jordan 1, 3, and 11, tend to command higher prices due to their iconic status and limited releases.

The condition of your Jordan shoes is another significant factor. Plato’s Closet looks for shoes that are gently worn, with minimal signs of use. Any damage, such as scuffs, stains, or sole separation, can lower the price they are willing to pay. It’s important to clean your shoes thoroughly and address any minor repairs or maintenance before bringing them to Plato’s Closet to maximize their value.

Additionally, the presence of original packaging, such as the shoebox, can impact the price Plato’s Closet offers. Shoes with their original boxes are generally more desirable to buyers and collectors, as they add to the overall authenticity and resale value. If you have the original box for your Jordan shoes, make sure to bring it along when selling them to Plato’s Closet.

Tips for Maximizing the Value of Your Jordan Shoes at Plato’s Closet

If you want to get the highest possible price for your Jordan shoes at Plato’s Closet, there are several strategies you can employ. First and foremost, make sure your shoes are clean and in the best possible condition. Take the time to remove any dirt or stains, and consider using a specialized sneaker cleaner to restore their original luster. Pay attention to the details, such as cleaning the midsole, laces, and any visible logos or branding.

Another tip is to provide any relevant information or documentation that can enhance the value of your Jordan shoes. If you have the original receipt, proof of purchase, or any certificates of authenticity, be sure to bring them with you. These additional documents can validate the authenticity and provenance of your shoes, potentially increasing their appeal to buyers and collectors.

Researching the Market Value of Your Jordan Shoes

Before heading to Plato’s Closet, it’s essential to do your homework and research the market value of your Jordan shoes. This step will help you understand the current market trends, pricing, and demand for the specific model you own. Websites and online marketplaces dedicated to sneaker reselling, such as StockX and GOAT, can provide valuable insights into the average selling prices for Jordan shoes.

Take the time to compare prices and listings for similar Jordan shoes in similar condition to yours. This research will give you a realistic expectation of what Plato’s Closet might offer. It’s important to note that Plato’s Closet operates as a thrift store and may not offer the same prices as specialized sneaker resale platforms. However, having a general understanding of the market value will help you negotiate a fair price and make an informed decision.

Alternatives to Plato’s Closet for Selling Jordan Shoes

While Plato’s Closet is a popular option for selling gently used clothing and accessories, including Jordan shoes, it may not always be your best choice. If you’re looking to maximize your earnings or have a rare, highly sought-after pair of Jordan shoes, exploring alternative platforms and methods can be beneficial.

Online Sneaker Marketplaces

Online sneaker marketplaces provide a platform specifically designed for buying and selling sneakers. Platforms like StockX, GOAT, and Grailed have a dedicated user base of sneaker enthusiasts and collectors, offering a larger pool of potential buyers. These platforms often have a verification process in place to authenticate the shoes, ensuring a safe and secure transaction.

When using online sneaker marketplaces, you have more control over the pricing of your Jordan shoes. You can set your desired asking price or even list them for auction, allowing buyers to bid on them. Keep in mind that these platforms may charge fees or commissions for their services, which can impact your final earnings.

Social Media and Sneaker Communities

Social media platforms, such as Instagram and Facebook, are also viable options for selling your Jordan shoes. Joining sneaker-focused groups, pages, or communities can connect you with potential buyers who are specifically interested in sneakers. Make sure to use relevant hashtags and provide detailed information about your shoes, including their condition, size, and any unique features.

When selling through social media, exercise caution and engage in safe practices. Verify the authenticity of potential buyers and consider using secure payment methods, such as PayPal, to protect yourself during the transaction.

Real-Life Experiences: Selling Jordan Shoes at Plato’s Closet

Curious about other people’s experiences selling Jordan shoes at Plato’s Closet? Let’s take a look at some real-life stories and testimonials from individuals who have gone through the process.

Case Study 1: John’s Success Story

John, an avid sneaker collector, decided to sell a pair of Air Jordan 4 Retro shoes at Plato’s Closet. He had taken excellent care of his shoes and ensured they were in pristine condition. When he brought them to Plato’s Closet, the staff was impressed by their condition and authenticity. After a thorough evaluation, Plato’s Closet offered John $120 for his Air Jordan 4 Retro shoes. Although the offer was lower than John’s initial expectations, he decided to accept it, considering the convenience and quick turnaround time.

Case Study 2: Sarah’s Disappointment

Sarah, a sneaker enthusiast, had a pair of Air Jordan 1 High OG shoes she was looking to sell. Unfortunately, her shoes had some noticeable scuffs and creases from regular wear. When she brought them to Plato’s Closet, they assessed the condition and offered her $60 for the shoes. Disappointed with the low offer, Sarah decided to explore other options and eventually sold her shoes through an online sneaker marketplace, where she received a higher price.

These case studies highlight the importance of considering your shoes’ condition and exploring different selling avenues to ensure you get the best value for your Jordan shoes.

Frequently Asked Questions About Selling Jordan Shoes at Plato’s Closet

Here are some frequently asked questions about selling Jordan shoes at Plato’s Closet:

Q: Can I negotiate the price Plato’s Closet offers for my Jordan shoes?

A: While Plato’s Closet has a general pricing structure, there might be room for negotiation depending on the specific pair of Jordan shoes you have and their condition. It’s always worth politely asking if they can increase their initial offer.

Q: How long does it take to sell Jordan shoes at Plato’s Closet?

A: The selling process at Plato’s Closet can vary depending on factors such as store location and staff availability. Generally, you can expect the evaluation and offer to be made within a relatively short period, often on the same day you bring your shoes in.

Q: Does Plato’s Closet buy all Jordan shoe models?

A: Plato’s Closet considers each pair of Jordan shoes individually, taking into account factors like condition, brand, style, and market demand. While they may not buy every model, they are typically interested in popular and sought-after Jordan shoe models.

Pros and Cons of Selling Jordan Shoes at Plato’s Closet

Selling your Jordan shoes at Plato’s Closet comes with both advantages and disadvantages. Let’s explore them in more detail:


  • Convenience: Plato’s Closet provides a quick and hassle-free selling experience, with the evaluation and payment process taking place in-store.
  • Immediate Payment: Once Plato’s Closet accepts your Jordan shoes, they will provide you with instant payment, allowing you to access your earnings immediately.
  • Reduced Effort: Selling your shoes at Plato’s Closet eliminates the needto deal with the complexities of online selling platforms or arranging meetups with potential buyers.
  • Broad Customer Base: Plato’s Closet has a wide customer base, including both sneaker enthusiasts and casual shoppers, increasing the chances of finding a buyer for your Jordan shoes.


  • Potential Lower Offers: As a thrift store, Plato’s Closet may offer lower prices compared to specialized sneaker resale platforms or selling directly to collectors.
  • Limited Expertise: While Plato’s Closet staff undergo training to assess items, their expertise may not match that of dedicated sneaker enthusiasts or collectors who are more knowledgeable about the sneaker market.
  • Restricted Availability: Plato’s Closet has specific store locations, so if there isn’t one near you, it may not be a convenient option for selling your Jordan shoes.

Tips for a Successful Selling Experience at Plato’s Closet

To ensure a successful selling experience at Plato’s Closet, consider the following tips:

1. Clean and Present Your Shoes Well

Take the time to thoroughly clean your Jordan shoes, removing any dirt, stains, or scuffs. Present them in the best possible condition to increase their appeal and value.

2. Bring Relevant Documentation

If you have any original receipts, certificates of authenticity, or proof of purchase, bring them along. These documents can validate the authenticity and provenance of your shoes.

3. Be Realistic with Your Expectations

Understand that Plato’s Closet operates as a thrift store and may not offer top-dollar prices for your Jordan shoes. Research the market value beforehand to have realistic expectations.

4. Explore Other Selling Options

If you’re looking for higher payouts or have rare, limited-edition Jordan shoes, consider exploring alternative platforms like online sneaker marketplaces or social media groups dedicated to sneakers.

5. Be Polite and Professional

Approach the selling process with a polite and professional demeanor. Building a good rapport with the staff can potentially lead to better offers or future opportunities.

Final Thoughts on Selling Jordan Shoes at Plato’s Closet

Selling your Jordan shoes at Plato’s Closet can be a convenient option, especially if you’re looking for a quick and hassle-free selling experience. However, it’s important to manage your expectations and understand that Plato’s Closet is a thrift store with its pricing structure. If you have rare or highly sought-after Jordan shoes, exploring specialized sneaker resale platforms or social media communities may yield higher payouts. Ultimately, consider your goals, the condition of your shoes, and the current market demand before deciding where to sell your beloved pair of Jordan shoes.

In conclusion, understanding how much Plato’s Closet pays for Jordan shoes involves considering multiple factors. By following the tips, doing your research, and managing your expectations, you can make an informed decision about selling your Jordan shoes at Plato’s Closet or exploring alternative options. Happy selling!

Related video of How Much Does Plato’s Closet Pay for Jordan Shoes?